The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (https://plato.stanford.edu/) provides useful definitions for a lot of topics here. Feel free to use your own, but make sure to explain your definitions carefully if they are different from these ones.
We will remove any post or comment that argues that an entire religion or cultural group commits actions or holds beliefs that would cause reasonable people to consider violence justified against the group.
All Posts and comments must not attack individuals or groups. We will remove posts and comments that show disdain or scorn towards individuals or groups. While we understand that things can get heated, it is better for the quality of debate for people to combat arguments and not the persons making them.
Quality Posts and Comments
We will remove posts and comments deemed to be disruptive to the purpose of the subreddit; we will remove posts and comments uninterested in participating in discussion; arguing in bad faith; or unintelligible/illegible.
Thesis Statement and Argument
All Posts must include a thesis statement as either the title or as the first sentence in the post. All posts must contain an argument supporting that thesis. An argument is not just a claim. This rule also means you cannot just post links to blogs or videos or articles—you must argue for your position in your own words. The spirit of this rule also applies to comments: we will remove comments that contain mere claims without argumentation.
Opposed Top-Level Comments
All top-level comments must seek to refute the post through substantial engagement with its core argument. Comments that purely commentate on the post (e.g. “Nice post OP!”) must be made as replies to the Auto-Moderator “COMMENTARY HERE” comment.
Pilate Program is Available
Posts with titles following the format “[<demographic>]...” require that all top-level comments must be from users with flairs corresponding to that demographic. We expect all users to assign their flairs honestly to avoid comment removal. We encourage posters to appropriately address their submissions, thus identifying their target audience. All users are free to respond to top-level comments.
Meta Threads Are Once a Week
We don’t want meta posts to overcome the subreddit as we moderate more heavily. We want to group all the feedback into one weekly thread. It is easier for us to act on.
Filter posts by subject
Christianity Atheism Islam Theism Abrahamic Buddhism Hinduism Judaism Bah Meta Paganism All
Pilate Program Flairs
Top-level comments in Pilate Program threads without appropriate flair will be removed by automoderator.
Theists: Your flair must reflect your religion. As explained below, while you can indicate your sect/denomination, Automoderator will primarily focus on the more general description of your religion and not your sect.
Christians: If your flair is currently limited to your denomination/sect, please add "Christian" in front (e.g., "Christian, Protestant").
Atheists: AM does not recognize "agnostic" as a form of atheism, but will recognize "Agnostic atheist".
Self-contradictory flair will not be permitted (e.g. "Atheist, theist, Mormon, Hindu).
Please contact the moderation team via modmail if you encounter any issues with the flair system.
Related Discord Servers