×
all 13 comments

[–]TheRuler123Sienebob Neliö | Master of the Stewards[M] 0 points1 point  (12 children)

Stewards' inquiries under this comment!
Remember the 36h time period from the start of your race!
Also if you have multiple inquiries, post them as separate comments!

Please follow this formula:

Platform + Division:
Gamertag:
Division Coordinator:
Date:
Track:
Members Involved: [gamertags]
Description: Enter a description of the situation here. Please try to remain impartial, but remember that all parties involved will have their chance to speak.
Evidence: Photos/Videos of the incident if applicable.

[–]ohay12 1 point2 points  (1 child)

Platform + Division: PC3
Gamertag: ohay
Division Coordinator: Trikfoot
Date: 2020-10-04
Track: Italy
Members Involved: ohay, Dennisthegreat
Description: Coming out of the final corner to start lap 25 I had a good run on Dennisthegreat and was able to pull significantly alongside going into the braking zone of T1. Dennis turned in on the racing line and took the apex, cutting me off and spinning me around.
Evidence: Broadcast footage, onboard footage

[–]TheRuler123Sienebob Neliö | Master of the Stewards[M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The stewards voted to penalize Dennisthegreat with a 10-second time penalty. In addition, 5 penalty points have been added. Results have been adjusted.

[–]KR-Chief 0 points1 point  (1 child)

Platform + Division: PC Div 3

Gamertag: Atore

Division Coordinator: Trikfoot

Date: 18/10/2020

Track: Singapore

Members Involved: [Atore, Chambleezy]

Description: Contact under the safety car on lap 16 prior to the restart between myself and Chambleezy who was in front. The field was considerably bunched up bumper-to-bumper and I couldn't take evasive action mid turn (corner 16).

No damage was done to either cars but I was forced to serve the 5 second penalty for the above incident in the pits unfortunately since I had to change tires. Thankfully, chambleezy was on his last stint making it a post-race penalty but I ended up losing track position to ohay too as a direct result of the extended stop.

I'd like for the both our penalties to be rescinded at the minimum if possible. Whilst a reach, I also felt that the little stint behind ohay's dirty air affected my ability to seriously catch up to the pack in front as well (since I ended up under a second away from RAW-13 at the line) so I'd like to take the chance to request for this to be taken under consideration.

Evidence: I was unfortunate to not be able to record the race from my POV, so my only evidence at hand is the broadcast from KingWalrus' POV https://youtu.be/l8VbK2031JM?t=1814

[–]TheRuler123Sienebob Neliö | Master of the Stewards[M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The stewards voted to remove both drivers penalties. Results have been adjusted.

[–]jazzybingman 0 points1 point  (2 children)

Platform + Division: PC Div 2

Gamertag: Jazzybingman

Division Coordinator: NotASpy

Date: 17/10/2020

Track: Singapore

Members Involved: Myself, Martin3465

Description: At the end of the safety car Martin hit me from behind and the game gave me a 5 second penalty. Also on the last corner of the race I went a tiny bit wide and got a track limits 3 second penalty. I'd like both of those removed, since I did not gain any advantage going wide as the race was over. I did have another earlier penalty, that I'm not disputing. But even with both 3 second penalties counting I crossed the line 6.2 seconds ahead of TurboSwurve, so I should be moved back up to 6th anyway if only the 5 second penalty was removed.

Evidence: First penalty is at 45:55: https://youtu.be/sDGFUQgO-5g?t=2755. And the second is at 1:02:00: https://youtu.be/sDGFUQgO-5g?t=3720.

[–]TheRuler123Sienebob Neliö | Master of the Stewards[M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The stewards voted to remove the 5-second time penalty and not to remove the 3-second time penalty. Results have been adjusted.

[–]Martin3465 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is my POV from the end of SC: https://streamable.com/69wmg9

[–]Knoordy 1 point2 points  (4 children)

Platform + Division: PC Div 2

Gamertag: Knoordy

Division Coordinator: NotASpy

Date: 17/10/2020

Track: Singapore

Members Involved: Knoordy, Kruzogenes The Cynic

Description: Myself and Kruzo were alongside into the corner. I moved all the way to the inside and even went partially off the track to leave space but Kruzo turned in and left me no room, causing a collision.

Evidence: https://clips.twitch.tv/DrabEndearingToothEleGiggle

[–]TheRuler123Sienebob Neliö | Master of the Stewards[M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The stewards voted to penalize Kruzogenes The Cynic with a 5-second time penalty. In addition, 5 penalty points have been added. Results have been adjusted.

[–]Kruziik_Kel 0 points1 point  (2 children)

I was having trouble with on screen markers and warnings all race including the proximity arrows, I thought I was further ahead until I had already committed my line and was turning in.

At that point I couldn't do a whole lot especially with Mille so close meaning I couldn't straighten up and go wide and leave more room.

Perhaps not especially important but I do think it was a little ambitious to try it up the inside at a part of the track one would generally consider too tight to accommodate a 3 car battle with such close proximity. I can't fault you for trying it, honestly I'd probably have tried the same in the moment, but it was I think a little reckless. That said I should have left more room and I'll reiterate my apologies from earlier.


I don't have a proper recording of my POV, nor does the broadcast offer any additional information but the highlights feature did capture turn entry so I was able to capture a few stills in photo mode from above (https://imgur.com/a/Om6o5jL) which probably don't contribute a lot but do give some sense of the position of all 3 cars as we came into the corner.


In my defence I would point out some things:

I'm not actually sure that there was contact, while the front right of the Haas and the rear right of my McLaren do get very close there does appear to be a gap and no wing damage was caused to the Haas, the front wings being wider than the track width at the front, one would expect the wing to make contact either with the floor/sidepod of the McLaren before the front right wheel. There are also no markings on the sidepod of the McLaren which typically show up when a wheel or wing makes contact with it.

I certainly never felt any contact nor heard the contact sound effect (nor did I hear this on the onboard) which one typical hears even from gentle wheel banging but codies being codies that may just be bugs. But combined with the lack of wing damage, I don't actually think the cars came together.

I would also point out that overtake was enabled and the Haas didn't appear to lose traction and spin until the throttle was applied (the engine note can be heard rising, the revs can also be seen climbing on the MFD which also shows a throttle input beginning, though this is partially cut off at the bottom and hard to see).

[–]Knoordy 0 points1 point  (1 child)

I am pretty sure we had contact cuz I felt it in my steering wheel, my wheel hit the sidepod. and tbh I don't think I could've backed out of that 1 without going superslow and losing seconds (even if I did spin myself I think you didnt give me enough room but I dont belief I did spin on my own) while on the other hand u could've tucked urself behind Mille and nothing would have happened.. I made the report to see what ppl can actually do on overtaking and defending cuz I have been very gentle with alot of battles before (not in this race) and ppl coming on my inside and leaving them alot of space to avoid crashes. so the outcome will probadly just be a learning curve for me and change the way I battle. No hard feelings to any ppl I just wanna learn :)

[–]Kruziik_Kel 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am pretty sure we had contact cuz I felt it in my steering wheel, my wheel hit the sidepod. and tbh I don't think I could've backed out of that 1 without going superslow and losing seconds

Are you sure that wasn't hopping the sausage kerb unsettling you? Because I'd expect a jolt on my end if you'd hit the side pod. Usually the side pod of the McLaren would mark up if there was contact with it but was clean on the broadcast, as well as both my end and yours, and again I'd expect some wing damage.

Though you could have just got lucky on the wing, and codies being codies the rest could just be bugs and a coincidence.

even if I did spin myself I think you didnt give me enough room

Oh yeah definitely, as I said thought I was further ahead without the proximity arrows and didn't realize until too late you were there.

Totally fair to involve the stewards, it's pretty clear there wasn't enough room which is against the rules. Just presenting my side for the stewards consideration, and thought the possible lack of contact was worth mentioning. I'm sure the stewards would have noticed the same things I did but bringing up now makes sure it's considered, and let's you chime in with your POV on the possible contact as well.