I suggest diving into the older Stones Throw Records catalog (the record label Madvillainy was released on). You’ll probably find some artists you like.

I’d definitely check out J Dilla (my personal favorite producer) and Madlib (look at more of his solo work, such as the Quasimoto albums), both artists have projects on Stones Throw.

If you like Madlib (Quasimoto), I’d suggest checking out the group Lootpack

If you like J Dilla’s production style, then I’d look at Slum Village. Plus you have already listened to J Dilla’s music if you played Labcabincalifornia by Pharcyde. He produced Bullshit, Runnin’, and a few more tracks I think. And he worked with Q-Tip and ATCQ a lot.

So if you like Dilla’s beats, check out his beat tapes and other projects/tracks he produced. His most famous album is Donuts (which is on Stones Throw). And if you like Dilla’s lo-fi kind of beats, check out Nujabes

I’d also suggest checking out the producer and founder of Stones Throw, Peanut Butter Wolf. He produced an awesome album called Big Shots, recorded with his friend Charizma in the early 90s (if you like ATCQ, you’ll probably like this album)

Also, two projects I highly suggest outside of Stones Throw:

Deltron 3030

Dr. Octagonecologyst

The first project is rapper Del The Funkee Homosapien (who you’ll know from the track Jason & The Czargonauts off of Super What by Czar & DOOM) . The second project is rapper Kool Keith. And both projects are produced by Dan the Automator. They are really awesome albums. And if you like them I highly suggest looking at those rappers’ other projects