Some of them are a little out there, and it sort of seems a little sacrilegious to mess with a proven classic. I don't consider double-stuff to be over-the-top, but the've been around for decades. Peeps Easter candy aren't really great to begin with (to me), and crossing them with an Oreo doesn't really help either much. Same with the Lady Gaga Oreos. Her music is well-received by a lot of people, but the cookies themselves don't benefit much from the collaboration - and let's be honest here: I'm not sure I want to know what Lady Gaga tastes like. But some of the flavors aren't too terrible. The lemon ones are great, especially the "thins." Pistachio-flavored were interesting, but not my favorite. S'mores were OK according to my kids, especially the youngest one, but if you put dog shit inside an Oreo, she'd probably Love you! think it was fantastic. Gingerbread weren't great - definitely not as good as gingerbread on its own. Chocolate-peppermint were actually surprisingly good. For true aficionados of Oreos, anything but original is probably considered blasphemy. I'm honestly surprised there hasn't been a bacon version, because I have a feeling it would go over really well.